Review: ‘Planes,’ by Peter C. Baker

PLANES, by Peter C. Baker


Amira. Ayoub. Melanie. Bradley. The names alone evoke 21st-century literary tension. Muslims, non-Muslims, men, women. There must be a story here.

Ayoub, a young Moroccan immigrant in Rome, is, for reasons we’ll never learn, extradited, sent to a secret prison and tortured. Amira, his Italian wife his, who converted to Islam, waits for him in a state of disciplined loneliness. Melanie is a real estate agent in North Carolina, where she serves as the liberal on the school board, worries about her son her in college and is having an affair with Bradley, her conservative opponent on the board. Bradley drives a pickup truck and owns the local airline that leases its planes to the US government to transport terrorism suspects. The couple in Rome stay in Rome and the couple in North Carolina stay there. They don’t know one another and will never meet.

In his debut novel, “Planes,” Peter C. Baker delicately crafts the internal lives of these very different people, whose longings for connections beyond themselves are forever missing the mark.

Self-delusion is partly responsible for their inability to connect. When approached by Melanie, who is angry that he has agreed to participate in extradition and torture, Bradley refuses to claim responsibility and later rationalizes his role his in the suffering of others : “Your country calls. You answer, and seeing the answer through lets you see up close the normally invisible gears turning beneath the surface of the world.”

Melanie is the most complicated of the four: She lies to her husband and son and yet strives to do right by the white-liberal standards set by her activist friends. The implication is that Melanie must imagine and then empathize with the lives her world her has disrupted or destroyed, and yet her empathy her is a dead end. She never meets Ayoub or even a man like him, and while her friends her are much more determined in their activism and whistle-blowing, Melanie remains in the background of her own story, quietly letting difficult conversations pass her by and second-guessing both her intuitions and actions her. While passivity of this kind might be true to life, portraying it like this in fiction — generally and without counterpoint — pulls energy from the narrative at large.

In pleasing contrast to the American couple, who seem flattened by their self-delusion, the couple in Rome are brought off the page by their complexity. Baker’s Rome is vivid and gritty, and unrecognizable to the casual tourist. The author is careful to withhold much of Ayoub’s experience, wisely avoiding voyeuristic details of the extradition or torture. Instead, we follow a man who suffers but also seeks a path forward, however narrow and winding. On the first day of his new job at a produce stall, Ayoub “keeps his head up, not seeking eye contact but not avoiding it either, letting people see that he is one of them, with somewhere to go and something to do when he gets there.” This quiet detail of confidence-building, of self-presentation, holds in it the author ‘s respect for his character his, who, like all good characters, is both weak and strong.

Credit…Jonathan Michael Castillo

The debate continues over whether imagining the other — writing outside one’s identity with respect and empathy — actually works in fiction. We live in a moment of great reckoning. Amira is an interesting contribution to the conversation. The specificity of her Esquilino neighborhood her, her nervous lunches her with an old flame, her satisfaction her in practicing Islam had me turning the book over to look at the author’s name her and wonder, How does this Baker know what it is like to be Amira?

While Ayoub is in prison, Amira lives in a state of asceticism, scheduling her days with work, walks and bland meals, as if pleasure while her husband is being tortured in prison is in itself a deceit. And yet she is not a victim. Baker complicates her until we come to see Amira as a woman in power, selecting the course of her life her and accepting whatever she might await. Her determinations her, the way she manages their stings and rewards, capture our shared human ache with stunning accuracy. I felt for her the immediate empathy one feels for a well-written character, and it is clear that Baker did, too. How we take that empathy forward is up to us; fiction only makes the introductions.


Laleh Khadivi’s most recent novel is “A Good Country.” She is the associate dean of graduate programs at University of San Francisco.


PLANES | By Peter C. Baker | 256 pp. | Alfred A. Knopf | $27

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.